Satellite survey links tropical park fires with poverty and corruption

We often argue that deforestation and rainforest fragmentation in the Global South is primarily driven by poverty. Lack of income, market access and modern agricultural techniques force small farmers to keep relying on destructive agricultural practises that yield low amounts of wealth, such as slash-and-burn subsistence farming. If they were to find new products and markets on which to sell highly valuable products, they could switch to modern farming techniques that require far less land and that are considerably more sustainable. One of Biopact's main arguments is that biofuels and biomaterials offer such a market and opportunities for substantially increased incomes, certainly now that oil prices remain high and will only keep rising in the future.

Forest-rich nations could decide to find sources of income in other sectors, but would then have to redistribute these to the poor farmers who are directly involved in destructive agricultural practises. We know most of these 'trickle-down' schemes will not work, though. Biofuels on the contrary can be produced by the farmers themselves, and allow them at least to retain some form of control over the incomes they generate.

One thing is clear though, poverty remains the key driver of deforestation. Scientists who undertook the first global assessment of forest fire control effectiveness in tropical parks have found the correlation again, by looking at which countries succeed best in conserving their tropical forest. Their results show that both poverty and corruption correlate closely with lack of fire protection in tropical moist forests. A better understanding of these links between corruption, poverty and park management will help conservationists and policy makers create sophisticated strategies to conserve tropical ecosystems. Helping local farmers gaining more income will be one of the more important drivers of such strategies.

The survey will be published in the July issue of Ecological Applications, reported by lead author S. Joseph Wright, staff scientist at the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute; Arturo Sanchez-Azofeifa and Carlos Portillo-Quintero from the University of Alberta; and Diane Davies from the University of Maryland.

Satellite data on fire frequency provides a measure of park effectiveness across countries. It is strikingly clear from our study that poverty and corruption limit the effectiveness of parks set up to protect tropical forests. - Joseph Wright, staff scientist at the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute

The survey indicates that parks were most effective at reducing fire incidence in Costa Rica, Jamaica, Malaysia and Taiwan; whereas parks failed to prevent fires in much poorer countries like Cambodia, Guatemala and Sierra Leone. Current integration of state-of-the-art remote sensing databases with Geographic Information Systems is allowed the scientists to better evaluate the effectiveness of conservation efforts in tropical environments.

While nearly all tropical countries have established parks to protect rainforests, not all have the political and economic means to enforce park boundaries and prevent illegal extraction of park resources. To better distinguish functional parks from 'paper' parks and to characterize the relationship between social factors and park protection worldwide, the team created an index comparing fire frequency inside and outside of 823 tropical and subtropical parks.

Low fire frequency within parks was chosen as an indicator of park effectiveness because the background level of fire in tropical moist forests is low, so the presence of fire often indicates that humans are engaged in timber extraction, clearing land for agriculture or other land-use conversion:
biomass :: bioenergy :: biofuels :: energy :: sustainability :: rainforests :: agriculture :: land-use :: poverty :: deforestation ::

The frequency was based on fire detection data from NASA�s satellite-based Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS). "The MODIS fire products enable us to monitor global fires and see how fire regimes are changing", says Chris Justice of the NASA MODIS fire team. He noted that information from the NASA Fire Information for Resource Management Information System Project provides a prototype to provide future long-term fire information from space tailored to the needs of resource managers.

Wright added that satellite data has limitations: "The satellite data must be carefully screened. Perhaps the clearest examples of this system's limitations were a park in Costa Rica and two parks in Indonesia where active volcanoes triggered the MODIS fire detection algorithm".

With fire frequency data in hand, researchers developed a set of social and economic indicators reflecting the level of poverty and corruption in each country. The Corruption Protection Index was provided by Transparency International; other information came from United Nations files and the CIA-World Fact Book.

As part of this publication, fire frequency data from 3,964 tropical reserves will be posted online. The authors hope that other investigators more familiar with reserves in particular countries or regions will use these data to better understand the causes of fires in parks and their management implications.

Picture: Fire near Soberania National Park, Panama. March, 2007. Credit: Christian Ziegler, Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute.

References:
Eurekalert: Satellite survey links tropical park fires with poverty and corruption - July 9, 2007.